Fourth Circuit Confirms Maryland Can Regulate Kalshi's Sports Prediction Contracts
A three‑judge Fourth Circuit panel upheld a district court's refusal to block Maryland's sports‑wagering rules on Kalshi's prediction contracts.
Key takeaways
- The Fourth Circuit denied Kalshi's request for a preliminary injunction, preserving Maryland's regulatory reach.
- Judges were divided on whether the contracts fall under the CEA's definition of swaps.
- The ruling joins the Sixth and Ninth Circuits against Kalshi, while the Third Circuit has ruled otherwise, creating a split among appellate courts.
A three‑judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed the district court’s August 1, 2025 decision rejecting Kalshi’s bid for a preliminary injunction, thereby allowing Maryland to enforce its sports‑betting statutes on the platform’s event‑based contracts.
Judicial disagreement over swap status
The unsigned opinion issued on Nov. 18, 2026 avoided a definitive ruling on whether Kalshi’s contracts qualify as “swaps” under the Commodity Exchange Act, a classification that would give the CFTC exclusive oversight.
Judge Gregory, joining the majority, said that even if the contracts were swaps, the traditional state role in gambling would not be displaced absent a clear congressional directive.
Judge Thacker added that the contracts do not meet the CEA’s definition of swaps, meaning they lie outside the CFTC’s sole jurisdiction and can be co‑regulated by Maryland.
In dissent, Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin argued the contracts are swaps subject to CFTC authority and would have reversed the lower‑court denial, sending the case back for further review.
Procedural history and appellate landscape
Maryland’s gaming commission mailed a cease‑and‑desist notice to Kalshi on April 7, 2025, demanding cessation of contract offerings without a state sports‑wagering license within 15 days.
Kalshi responded with a lawsuit on April 21, 2025, asserting that the Commodity Exchange Act preempts Maryland’s rules; District Judge Adam Abelson denied the injunction request on Aug. 1, 2025.
The Fourth Circuit’s decision aligns with rulings from the Sixth and Ninth Circuits, which also rejected Kalshi’s preemption claim, while the Third Circuit has ruled in Kalshi’s favor, producing a split that could attract Supreme Court attention, according to Austin Campbell of Unchained.
Friend‑of‑the‑court briefs supporting Maryland were filed by Nevada, Ohio, 36 additional states and the District of Columbia, emphasizing a coordinated state stance on gambling regulation.
Kalshi’s position was bolstered by amicus filings from investment firm Paradigm and sports‑betting platform Underdog Sports, which advocated for a uniform federal framework under the CEA.
Potential impact on jurisdictional boundaries
Should a future court determine the contracts are swaps, the CFTC would gain exclusive control, potentially limiting state licensing requirements; the current majority’s refusal to decide leaves that question open for later litigation.
Judge Thacker’s view that the contracts are not swaps mirrors the Ninth Circuit’s earlier Nevada decision, reinforcing a trend that some courts see these products outside CFTC purview.
Judge Benjamin’s dissent reflects the Third Circuit’s opposite stance, highlighting the legal uncertainty for prediction‑market operators operating nationwide.
Judge Gregory’s concurrence underscored that, without an explicit congressional statement, states retain concurrent authority over gambling‑related activities, a principle that guided the panel’s affirmation of Maryland’s rule.
Sources
Get stories like this in your inbox
The day’s biggest crypto stories and market moves in one short morning email. Free, no spam.