XRPL Hackathon at Blockchain Kaigi 2026 (Tokyo) | Dec 9, 2026 | Sumida City
Regulation

Manhattan Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum MEV Fraud Case

U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke dismissed all wire‑fraud and money‑laundering charges against Anton and James Peraire‑Bueno, ending the first‑of‑its‑kind prosecution.

white concrete building under sky
Photo Katie Moum on Unsplash

Key takeaways

  • Judge Jessica Clarke granted a judgment of acquittal on Nov. 16, 2026, clearing the brothers of wire fraud, conspiracy and money‑laundering charges.
  • Prosecutors failed to show a material misrepresentation, a required element for wire‑fraud convictions, according to the ruling.
  • The $25 million exploit targeted sandwich‑trading bots via a bug in Flashbots’ MEV‑Boost relay code in April 2023.

A Manhattan federal judge has dismissed all criminal charges against Anton and James Peraire‑Bueno, the MIT‑educated siblings accused of siphoning roughly $25 million from Ethereum trading bots in 2023. U.S. District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke issued a judgment of acquittal on Nov. 16, 2026, finding that prosecutors could not prove the brothers made a material misrepresentation—a core element of wire‑fraud law. The decision closes the case without a retrial, ending a prosecution that the government described as the first of its kind.

EthereumETH · 24h
$1,810−0.94%

Judge Clarke wrote that the government’s theory hinged on the allegation that the brothers lied about how they executed their trades. Under federal wire‑fraud statutes, a false or misleading statement must be material to the transaction. The court concluded that the brothers’ “bait” transactions, which were publicly posted to the blockchain, did not involve false promises or deceptive statements, and therefore did not satisfy the statutory requirement. Because the money‑laundering count was predicated on a wire‑fraud conviction, it fell with the fraud charges, as reported by Decrypt and Unchained.

What the exploit involved

The 2023 attack exploited a vulnerability in the MEV‑Boost relay software, an open‑source tool used by Ethereum validators to outsource transaction ordering to specialized block builders. The brothers placed bait transactions designed to attract “sandwich” bots—automated traders that place orders on either side of a target trade to capture maximal extractable value (MEV). By leveraging a bug in the relay’s code, they could view the private bundles submitted by the bots before the block was finalized, then replace the bait with their own trades that sold the targeted tokens. The operation drained about $25 million from the bots in roughly twelve seconds, after which Flashbots patched the relay within 24 hours.

Implications for crypto law and future prosecutions

Legal experts see the ruling as a signal that federal prosecutors must meet a higher evidentiary bar when applying traditional fraud statutes to decentralized protocols that lack formal terms of service. Coin Center’s Peter Van Valkenburgh called the decision “excellent news,” noting that the judgment limits the government’s ability to impose its own standards of conduct on open‑network participants. The case also echoes a 2025 Manhattan decision that cleared a Mango Markets trader on similar grounds, suggesting a developing jurisprudence around code‑based exploits and wire‑fraud charges.

What to watch next

The acquittal may prompt the Justice Department to reassess its strategy for pursuing code‑based attacks on blockchain platforms. Watch for any new indictments that attempt to frame similar exploits under alternative statutes, such as computer‑fraud or securities laws. Additionally, the Ethereum community is likely to monitor further developments in MEV‑Boost security and any regulatory commentary that could affect validator incentives.

Frequently asked questions

Why was the wire‑fraud charge dismissed?

The judge found prosecutors did not demonstrate a material misrepresentation, which is required for a wire‑fraud conviction.

What is MEV‑Boost?

MEV‑Boost is open‑source software that lets Ethereum validators outsource transaction ordering to specialized block builders to capture maximal extractable value.

Sources

  1. ProtosCode is Law: Judge acquits ‘MEV brothers’ over $25M Ethereum exploit
  2. NewsBTCJudge Acquits Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum MEV Case After Finding No Proven Wire Fraud
  3. Bitcoin.com NewsJudge Acquits MIT-Educated Brothers in $25M Ethereum Exploit Case
  4. UnchainedJudge Acquits ‘MEV Brothers’ in $25 Million Ethereum Case, Finding No Misrepresentation
  5. CointelegraphUS judge clears brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV case after mistrial
  6. DecryptJudge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Case, Ending Prosecution
Get stories like this in your inbox

The day’s biggest crypto stories and market moves in one short morning email. Free, no spam.

No spam, unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Not financial advice. This article is for information only. Crypto assets are highly volatile and you can lose all of your investment. See our Financial Risk Disclosure.
Anton Peraire-BuenoJames Peraire-BuenoMEV-BoostWire fraudJessica ClarkeEthereumInstitutions